NARS vs. Maybelline vs. NYX | Concealer Comparison
Let’s play a game where you match the swatch with the brand of concealer in the photo above. I’ll reveal the answers at the end of this post after showing and explaining daily photos of how these contestants performed being used exactly the same way. Here are the swatches:
I wore exactly the same makeup every day, with the exception of the eyeshadow on my lid (I was either wearing MAC Woodwinked or Urban Decay Bordello on alternating days). The concealer was used under the eyes. None of the photos have been retouched and were all taken with flash because it was dark outside. Notice any differences?
// Day 1 //
// Day 2 //
// Day 3 //
// Day 4 //
Ready for the answers and my feedback on each concealer? Look below!
Day 1: 3; Day 2: 4; Day 3: 2; Day 4: 1
They all came out pretty much the same, right? NARS $29 concealer looks almost identical to the other three $5-8 concealers. There are some slight nuances, however. I’ll go day by day:
NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer // $29 This formula applies the nicest in regards to creaminess. It has the most noticeable ‘real life’ brightening effect, but once it’s set with powder and all of my other makeup was on, I couldn’t tell a difference.
NYX HD Concealer // $4.99 I’ve been a fan of this product for awhile, except the doe-foot applicator is extremely cheap. It has seemed to lose its little fuzzies and basically applies to my face with just the plastic wand (I am careful not to poke my eyeballs out when using this). Also, the cap’s black covering broke off and now I just have a weird white plastic cap. I guess that’s why it’s the cheapest! It has a very similar texture to the NARS formula.
Maybelline Master Conceal // $7.94 I sang the praises of this concealer here, and this formula most closely resembled the look and feel of the NARS in regards to brightness and coverage abilities, but it does dry down quick and isn’t as forgiving on dry skin… at least under the eyes.
Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser // $7.94 This is a great every day concealer for those of you with moderate under eye circles. It’s great for all ages and can work on blemishes or skin discolorations nicely. It’s a sheer, gel-like (almost seems like a serum) texture and sits on the skin very nicely – doesn’t dry out skin or get too greasy. It really doesn’t compare to any of the above options, but I know it’s a favorite among many. I use it for quick makeup days but if I need more coverage, I go for any of the others listed above.
The takeaway? The photos prove that they all look extremely similar to me when all is said and done. So maybe choose to save $20, pick up one of the drugstore options and also get a new lipstick! Those red/orange lips seen on the beautiful Margot Robbie at the Oscars last night are totes up my alley.
-Steffanie
*Brighter, Darling utilizes some affiliate links which may generate a small commission from clicks that result in a purchase.
Great post!! I love NARS creamy concealer but I need to move on because it’s an expensive habit!!
Oh I understand!! Lots of good and cheaper options out there now that I know for sure 😉 good luck on your hunt and glad I could help!
really good review!! Too bad i haven’t been using any of those since i discovered the Pro Longer Concealer…. Would love to try the Nars one tho… but it’s hard to find here in Sweden.:(
I have never tried prolongwear just because that packaging with the pump would drive me crazy lol. They need to repackage that stuff!
Hahaha I know you need to be careful how much you pump out of it…. but it’s an amazing concealer… no crease and long lasting!
Wonderful comparison! I personally love my NARS Creamy Concealor… I really want to try the Maybelline Age Rewind, but unfortunately they don’t carry them in Asia at the moment. But I’ll admit when it comes to base products I’m a bit of a high end addict! But this goes to show drugstore concealers can look amazing! You are looking flawless, total skin envy here.
Oh, thank you! I have to give credit to my foundation 🙂
Oh! May I ask what foundation is it?
Urban Decay Naked Skin. One of my tip-top favorites!
Thank you for the recommendations. I was just starting to look into a better concealer being as I’ve noticed what I have hasn’t been doing the trick. You look beautiful, btw. : )
Hello! I’ve nominated you for a Liebster Award as I think your blog is really nice. Please check out the page, you’re mentioned in it too with questions to answer 🙂 http://simplybeautylove.com/2015/03/02/liebster-award-nomination/
Best wishes, Kirsty xx
I just bought the creamy concealer from NARS and I’m still not sure if it lives up to the hype, but it does go on so creamy and blends beautifully. This is an awesome post.
Paula
My beauty and lifestyle blog
I love this review, so so much! Comparing more expensive brands with more budget-friendly things. And you look absolutely perfect.
xx naomi @ Naomi in Wonderland
Me too!! I love me some sephora makeup but let’s be honest… My bank account does not, haha. Thanks for the kind words 🙂
loved the review. your blog is mos def sooo darling. you gained yourself a new follower my dear. keep it up! and look forward to more!
Wow that’s awesome because I couldn’t notice any difference at all! Sometimes I totally overlook drugstore products but this post reminds me to actually look beyond just Nars and my regular go-to brands.
Julia // The Sunday Mode